Hey all,
so i received quite a number of good responses over my ‘eyeliner fight off’ post, so i thought that this would be a good follow up to that post.
Welcome to the next round. The Eyebrow Pencil Fight off round.
First let us take a look at the contenders.
From top to bottom, YSL, Too Cool for School, Faceshop and lastly the oh so famous Anastasia Beverly Hills
Round 1: Ease of use and application
I would say that they were all pretty easy to use. But too cool for school had the least room for error. This is because the formulation they use is liquid, and it is very quick drying too. Once it is on there, you would need a make up remover to remove it. I personally like the YSL one the most, simply because it is the most user-friendly one, though pigmentation wise, it probably has the least pigment, i think that makes it alot more beginner friendly. I like the faceshop one the least, as a pencil, i think combing your brows is an essential step, yet the faceshop does not have a spoolie brush attached at the end of their pencils, which makes it very annoying when you are in a rush, cause you will have to rummage through everything to find a spoolie brush. The most convinient one though i believe is the Anastasia one. I am not sure if it was a coincidence, or if their research team really thought everything through, but when traveling, this is my go to brow pencil. Firstly there is a brush attached, and the best part is you wont need a sharpener. Oh yeah.
Round 2: Swipe and rub test.
I tried to rub it off once with my fingers, and once with a piece of tissue. As you can see, too cool for school held up the best. When you rub or dab it off with a piece of tissue, most of the product still manages to stay visible, but when you use your fingers to rub it, most of the product goes away completely. As you can see on the photo on the left, The right side, i used my fingers to rub the product off, you can see that with the exception of too cool for school, the rest of the brands had almost nothing left.
Last round: ( I did this just for fun, cause i didnt expect them to be waterproof anyways) Water Resistant test
I used abit of water to test how they would hold up, i placed the water on the right side of my had, and as you can see none, except too cool for school held up. This is expected though, as there is a difference in formulation. Gel type formulations would probably hold up best, followed by liquid formulation and then pencil and lastly powder.
Anyways, i hope this was as helpful if not at least entertaining for you.
Till then!
D